Secession Right – an Anti-Federal Principle? Comparative Study of Federal States and the EU


  •  Florentina Harbo Harbo    

Abstract

This article argues that the secession right is incompatible with federalism. The right of secession is one of the main criteria to differentiate a federal state from a confederation and a Bund. There are only a few federal states that recognised the secession right in their constitutions and they failed. On the other hand, there are even confederations which did not accept a secession right in their treaties. The issue of secession has always been very controversial in the European Union, which is a Bund (federal polity), but its Treaties never included it. The radical change is the introduction of Art. I-60 in the Treaty Establishing a Constitution for Europe (“Reform Treaty” now), which might give a new face to the EU if ever it is ratified.



This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
  • ISSN(Print): 1913-9047
  • ISSN(Online): 1913-9055
  • Started: 2008
  • Frequency: quarterly

Journal Metrics

Google Scholar Citations

h-index (2017): 14

i10-index (2017): 39

h5-index (2017): 9

h5-median (2017): 11

Contact